Reading Round Ups

15 Must-Read Psychological Thrillers

I have read A LOT of thrillers. (Check my Goodreads if you don’t believe me. Actually, please don’t. My to-read list is a cry for help.) But the ones that really stick with me are the psychological thrillers: the ones that mess with your head, make you question every single character, and have you texting a friend at 11 p.m. with “WHAT DID I JUST READ?”

Recently, I went back through everything I’ve rated four stars or higher and pulled together the fifteen I’d hand to anyone who asked, “Okay, but what should I read?” They’re in no particular order, because ranking them would honestly give me a headache. Think of this as a stack of books I’d happily force on you.

The Good Girl by Mary Kubica

Mia Dennett is the daughter of a powerful Chicago judge, and she goes home with the wrong guy from a bar. What follows is told from several perspectives and bounces between “before” and “after,” so you’re constantly piecing together who knows what. It earned a five-star rating from me, and Kubica’s twist is the kind that makes you flip back to see what you missed. Read my full review here.

The Couple Next Door by Shari Lapena

A dinner party next door. A baby at home. A baby monitor. And then the worst possible thing happens. I read this one twice (that’s how you know it’s good), and I’ll say what I always say about Lapena: she can build a “wait, WHO would do this?” feeling like no one else. My full review is here.

The Better Liar by Tanen Jones

This book was sooooo good. I was surprised by the twist. Then another. And another! It’s a con story at heart, with a plot that keeps shifting under your feet, and it’s one of those books where you’ll want to read just one more chapter until it’s suddenly 1 a.m.

When She Returned by Lucinda Berry

A mix of psychology and a cult? Does it get any more intriguing? Lucinda Berry has become one of my favorite authors, and this is the one I recommend first. I couldn’t put it down. If you finish it and want more, her Under Her Care and The Secrets of Us are both worth your time too.

The Good Sister by Sally Hepworth

Fern is the “good sister,” the one who would do anything for her twin, Rose. But the more you read, the more you wonder what that really means. This book has one of those endings that makes you say “WHAT AN ENDING” out loud to an empty room. I couldn’t put it down, and I’m still telling people to order it NOW.

The House Across the Lake by Riley Sager

Casey is a recently widowed actress who spends her days drinking and watching her neighbors with binoculars. When the wife next door vanishes, Casey is determined to figure out what happened. My honest review after finishing it was “WTF did I just read?” (in the best way). It floored me, and I did not see it coming. If you want a spooky, twisty lake-house read, this is it. Now, if you’re familiar with Sager (or you aren’t…I don’t know that it matters), this book was VERY divisive amongst his fans.

None of This Is True by Lisa Jewell

Alix Summers is a podcaster who meets a woman named Josie in a restaurant. They share a birthday, and Alix thinks Josie would make a great subject for her next podcast. Spoiler: that is a terrible idea. Lisa Jewell is a master at slowly tightening the screws, and this one earned five stars from me.

Hidden Pictures by Jason Rekulak

Mallory Quinn is a recovering addict who takes a job as a nanny for a young couple’s five-year-old son, Teddy. Teddy loves to draw, but his pictures start to show something unsettling, and Mallory becomes convinced they’re trying to tell her something. It’s creepy, clever, and has a few twists I did not see coming. I gave it five stars, and it’s the book I’d grab if you want a slow, shivery build-up that really pays off.

Defending Jacob by William Landay

What would you do if your 14-year-old son was accused of murdering a classmate, and you were the assistant district attorney working in the very office that was prosecuting him? This is a slow-burn legal thriller that’s really about how well you can ever know someone, even your own child. It’s the book I’ve been on the phone arguing about with friends. I wrote about it here.

Dark Matter by Blake Crouch

Okay, this is my wildcard, because it’s technically science fiction. BUT it is also a psychological thriller about identity, choice, and the lives we didn’t live, so it makes the list. A physicist is abducted and wakes up in a world that is almost his own. I picked it up at random from the library, expecting nothing, and it blew me away. I’ve now read it twice, and Blake Crouch is officially my go-to author for when I want my mind a little bit scrambled. Even my dad enjoyed this one, and he’s not much of a sci-fi guy.

Before I Disappear by Cate Quinn

This one only hit shelves on November 10, so it’s about as fresh as recommendations get. Dr. April Anderson, a criminologist, wakes up in a motel room with a serious head injury and no memory of how she got there. A cop is guarding her, her fiancé is secretly tracking her, and she can’t be sure which of them to trust. It earned a solid 4.5 stars from me. If you love an amnesia plot (and a heroine who is rightfully annoyed with her own brain), put this one on your list.

My Husband’s Wife by Alice Feeney

Eden Fox is an artist about to have her big break. She heads out for a run before her first exhibition, and when she gets back, another woman is living in her house and claiming to be her husband’s wife. From there, Feeney (the “queen of twists”) does what she does best, and nothing is quite what it seems. I gave this one five stars, and it’s the one I’d hand to anyone who loves a story that keeps rearranging itself.

Pretty Girls by Karin Slaughter

In Pretty Girls, a woman’s life is turned upside down when her husband is killed, which pulls her back toward the long-ago disappearance of her sister. She and her estranged sister have to dig into what really happened, and the answers are not pretty. Fair warning: this one is dark and intense. It earned five stars from me, and it’s the one I’d pick if you want a thriller with real emotional weight.

The Last Housewife by Ashley Winstead

Shay Evans has built a polished life, but in college she and her best friends fell under the spell of a magnetic, controlling man. When her friend Laurel is found dead, Shay goes back to the past she tried so hard to bury to find out what really happened. It’s a dark, propulsive story about power, control, and getting out, and it earned five stars from me. Heads up: there are heavy content warnings (including a cult, sexual violence, and suicide), so check them before you dive in.

It’s Not What You Think by Clare Mackintosh

Nadeeka is certain her partner, Jamie, is cheating. When he says he’s working late, she knows he’s lying, so she races home to catch him in the act. What she finds instead is something she never could have imagined. Mackintosh has a reputation for knockout twists, and this one has been billed as her biggest yet. I gave it four stars, and it’s a great pick if you like to go in knowing as little as possible.

Your turn

There you have it, fifteen thrillers I’d happily recommend to anyone. If you’ve read any of them, I want to hear what you thought (especially if you saw the twists coming, because I’m still bitter about the ones I missed). If I left your favorite psychological thriller off this list, tell me in the comments. My to-read pile is apparently not big enough yet.

You can shop this whole list (and a whole bunch of other books) on my Amazon Storefront. These also make great gift ideas for the reader in your life!

Happy reading!

Note: This post contains affiliate links, so I may receive a small commission from sales generated (at no extra cost to you).